Saturday, February 05, 2005

Personal Social Security Accounts

I continue to find more supporting evidence for my proposals on how to handle Personal Social Security Accounts. Briefly, I would create such accounts and also increase the amounts individuals could contribute beyond the President’s proposal by gradually eliminating the mortgage interest deduction on your income tax. Here are links to articles in The Wall Street Journal (once again, I do not know if they work for non-subscribers - Can I get a little help here, Lee?).
This article from the 2/4/05 edition, page A5 has a sub-headline “Bush's Social Security Plan Requires More Than 3% Real Rate of Return To Come Out Ahead” That’s not too tough! Can anyone find a period where long term fixed mortgages cost less then a 3% real annual rate? Prepaying is the financial equivalent to Einstein’s General Theory of Relativity. Reducing your obligations is the reverse side of the investing coin!

This opinion piece by Peggy Noonan from the 2/4/05 edition, page A8, asks “Here I raise a question about human nature that I cannot answer. Republicans tend to assume that everyone hungers for more investment accounts to handle. This is because Republicans like personal autonomy and authority, and are good at math. Others might reasonably wonder if life isn't complicated enough. The beauty of the Social Security system is its almost idiotic simplicity: They take your money from your paycheck and then 40 years later when you're old they start giving some back each month. Personal accounts are less simple.” So using the funds to prepay your mortgage, an already existing account, solves your problem doesn’t it, Peggy?

This column by James H. Hagerty from the 1/31/05 edition, page A2 notes “…it is time to rethink the deduction. Defenders of the deduction depict it as a way of helping more people afford to buy a home. In fact, the deduction does little to boost homeownership. The vast bulk of the benefits go to people who could easily afford a home even without a tax break. Nearly 80% of the benefits from the mortgage-interest and property-tax deductions go to the top 20% of taxpayers in terms of income, according to the Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy in Washington. Only 5% of the benefits go to people in the bottom 60% of the income scale -- those who may be struggling to afford a home.

"People making over $100,000 are the biggest beneficiaries," says Bart Harvey, chief executive of the Enterprise Foundation, Columbia, Md., which helps fund housing for low-income people. "No one says, 'This is ridiculous. This doesn't compute.' "
The cost of the mortgage-interest deduction for owner-occupied residences, in terms of forgone revenue for the government, is estimated at $69.9 billion for fiscal 2005. The deduction for property taxes costs an additional $16.7 billion, while the tax-free treatment of capital gains on sales of principal residences comes to $18 billion. Together, these breaks are by far the biggest government subsidy for housing.
One reason the benefits go mainly to the rich is that the mortgage-interest deduction is available only to people who itemize deductions on their tax returns. Few low-income people itemize because they can do better by taking the standard deduction. As a result, the mortgage-interest deduction serves largely to encourage wealthy people to spend more on housing because it cuts their aftertax cost of borrowing. That encourages builders to concentrate more of their resources on luxury homes and less on ordinary ones.
Another reason the wealthy benefit disproportionately is that the tax code allows homeowners to deduct the interest on mortgage debt totaling as much as $1 million. That makes it easier for the well-heeled to also deduct the interest on a second home.”

He notes further
“Though the deduction is considered untouchable by most U.S. politicians, Britain managed to phase out a similar break for mortgage interest over 12 years, ending in 2000. There was no crash in house prices, which kept rising, and no taxpayer revolt. In the U.S., the problem with proposals for even modest change is that some of the country's most powerful lobbies oppose any reduction in the tax benefits.” So it is politically possible!

10 Comments:

Blogger Toni said...

I think that's a pretty darn good idea too. Even though I would get pinged from it and not reap anything on the SS side (too old) I still think it's a good way to approach the issue. The other reason is to get people off the dependence on this deduction so potentially the US could move to a fairer tax system. Personally, I like the consumption model cause it picks up taxes from all so all have a stake. Not like today where almost 50% of the taxpaying public don't pay any taxes (Federal Income). But I also know a consumption tax chance is slim and none so anything remotely approaching a flat tax would be welcomed.

6:54 AM  
Blogger Get-A-Free-House said...

How Would You Like To Know How YOU Can Live In A Beautiful NEW House That Is Custom-Designed To YOUR Specifications.........And At NO COST To You?

You CAN Do It. And It's Not Hard To Do.... IF You Know HOW.

Don't Let This Pass You By Without At Least Taking A Look.

The Only Catch Is That You HAVE To Have An Income ABOVE $21,000...... And......You HAVE To Follow The Easy Instructions Provided To You.

Get-A-Free-House.com

4:04 PM  
Blogger Ray said...

I really love your blog!

I've bookmarked it and told my blogger freak friends about it. It's intelligent, sometimes funny and always refreshingly honest. Keep Up The Good Work!

For any of your readers who want to contribute to the Red Cross to aid the many families who have been devastated by Katrina and Rita, and now the awful earthquake in Asia, there is a link to the Red Cross at my ##KEYWORD## site.


I really love your blog!

I've bookmarked it and told my blogger freak friends about it. It's intelligent, sometimes funny and always refreshingly honest. Keep Up The Good Work!

For any of your readers who want to contribute to the Red Cross to aid the many families who have been devastated by Katrina, there is a link to the Red Cross here.

All best best going forward!

Ray

12:41 PM  
Blogger Ray said...

You've got a very informative blog.

I've gotten some good information here, so I've bookmarked your blog and will return often for the latest. If you have time, check out my home mortgage reverse site.

Thanks and all the best in the future.

Bob

1:46 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

This is the kind of site I've been looking for. Definitely bookmarkable! If you get a chance, can you check out current mortgage rate . I'm fairly new to building websites, and would value any opinions
on my current mortgage rate site.

5:55 PM  
Blogger Ray said...

Finally, a blog with really useful and interesting information. Not that other blogs aren't good as well, but your's stands out, that's for sure.

You probably spend a lotta time at it, but it's worth it to your readers, that's for sure.

My ct mortgage reverse resource site provides good information, I hope people find useful. If you have any ideas for me, that's great...It's my first site.

James

12:25 AM  
Blogger The Answer Man said...

Learn How The SMART Real Estate Investors Get RICH....And Its' NOT With Rentals, Forclosures Or The "Fix And Flip"

Game.....

Click Here For More Information



Rehab

2:15 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

You have done a great job on setting up your Blog. Your site will definately be bookmarked.

I am in the process of setting up a investing kid
site. It's basically a resource site which covers investing kid
related stuff.

Please let me know what you think if you have time to check it out.

5:43 AM  
Blogger De Post Man said...

Nice posts. Check out my site http://mortgage.27days27gurus.com/ if you get a chance. mortgage one option

12:34 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Nice site. Check mine out if you can. shirt sleeve investing

12:38 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home